Yankees and Mets lag behind younger, superior teams

By Hugo Mercer June 24, 2023

As the Yankees and Mets struggle with player development and aging lineups, teams like the Braves, Orioles, and Reds find success through cultivating homegrown talent and conducting smart trades.

Bill Parcells famously stated, "you are what your record says you are." Both the Yankees and Mets seem to embody this sentiment, with the teams ahead of them in the standings unlikely to be surpassed this season or the next. The absence of Aaron Judge in the Yankees' lineup reveals a lack of All-Star caliber players, while the Rays and Orioles showcase superior, younger, and more athletic talent throughout their rosters. In contrast, despite New York Mets' owner Steve Cohen's extensive investment, the Atlanta Braves demonstrate that there is no substitute for cultivating one's homegrown talent, especially when it comes to pitching.

Ranking first and second in the league for payroll, both the Mets and Yankees continue to falter around fourth place within their respective divisions. This highlights a significant investment in free agency but a lack of player development. The Yankees, with an average age of 30.39, are the oldest team in the American League. Key players such as Stanton, Rizzo, LeMahieu, Donaldson, and Torres face declining careers, and their player development system offers no authentic replacements.

The Yankees and Mets share a common problem—being trapped behind stronger teams in the standings. The Baltimore Orioles are a team worth watching in the American League, as their young core continues to improve significantly. Recent top draft picks, including outfielders Cowser and Kjerstad and shortstop Westburg, are all excelling at Triple-A Norfolk and are expected to contribute to the Orioles' major league roster soon.

Regarding the talent gap, the Mets, at an average age of 31.44, are the oldest team in Major League Baseball. They face a substantial challenge in keeping pace with the Braves, who consistently excel in player development. While the Braves have cultivated an efficient and cost-effective starting rotation, the Mets are burdened with a high-priced rotation that ranks 26th worst in the league in terms of ERA. A failure to draft and develop frontline starting pitchers has forced the Mets to pay hefty salaries for veteran players like Scherzer and Verlander.

Unexpectedly, the Cincinnati Reds have surged into first place in the NL Central, thanks to a recent 12-game winning streak. As a result of successful drafts and trades, the Reds roster now boasts a strong core of young talent. With Reds icon Votto's return, the team's lineup is further strengthened, although there is now increased competition at first base.

Lastly, former Yankee reliever George Frazier, the singular pitcher in history to lose three World Series games, sadly passed away last Monday at the age of 68. Frazier was remembered as a lively and passionate individual who transitioned from a successful playing career to a long tenure as a broadcaster for the Colorado Rockies. Rest in peace.